Mr Jakob Widner

Jakob Widner

Lawyer biography




German and English

Admitted to Practice

Austria 1999
New York 2002

Areas of Specialization

Employment Law, Expatriates, Data Protection
Life Sciences
Corporate Law


Master of Laws: NYU School of Law, 2001
Magister Juris: University of Vienna, 1992

Professional Experience

Partner with Graf & Pitkowitz since 1999
Associate with Graf, Maxl & Pitkowitz, 1997-1999
Associate with Spitzy & Lenzinger, Vienna, 1994 -1997


Austrian Bar (Vienna Bar Association)
New York State Bar Association


"Betriebspensionen bei Insolvenz nicht sicher", Der Standard 22 June 2011
Employment Law Review 2010, 2011
Practical Law Company, Data Protection Handbook 2011/2012
Altersteilzeit: AMS hat zu viel zurückgefordert, Der Standard 23 February 2011
"ÖBB hat Recht auf Gegenbeweis des Krankenstands", Gastkommentar in Der Standard, September 2009
Practical Law Company, Outsourcing Handbook, 2011/12
Practical Law Company, Outsourcing Handbook, 2009
International Law Office, Employment & Labour - Austria, seit 2008
Kolumne: „Alles was Recht ist", Die Presse, seit 2008
Getting The Deal Through, Labour & Employment, 2006


Employment & Immigration

Competitive actions by employees through intermediaries: imputation of liability and restrictive covenants
Austria | 04 November 2020

Under Section 7 of the Employment Act, employees cannot, while employed and without their employer's consent, operate a commercial business or conclude commercial transactions in their employer's line of business. In a recent case, the Supreme Court had to decide whether the statutory prohibition also covers such competitive actions by employees through intermediaries or whether only the employees themselves have the standing to be sued by their employer.

Supreme Court rules on compensation for illegal GPS tracking
Austria | 16 September 2020

The Supreme Court recently ruled for the first time on the issue of whether GPS tracking without an employee's consent warrants compensation for immaterial damage. Employers that use GPS tracking systems or similar control measures to monitor their staff should ensure that they agree the system's introduction with the works council or have each affected employee expressly consent to such a measure if no works council has been elected.

Supreme Court rules on formal requirements for dismissal challenge
Austria | 22 July 2020

The Supreme Court recently clarified the legal implications of one particular scenario of dismissal challenges: if a works council expressly objects to an employee's dismissal (as opposed to expressly consents or fails to make a statement), the right to challenge the dismissal rests with the works council, but only if the employee, within one week of such objection, requests the works council to act accordingly and file a lawsuit.

Continued remuneration during COVID-19 pandemic
Austria | 13 May 2020

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused employers to use various methods to support employees and maintain business performance. Old and new legal remedies provide for continued payment of salaries (and in some cases also corresponding grants to employers) if performance of work is impossible. This article outlines the routes that employers and employees can take where normal working is impossible, such as sick leave and care leave to look after sick children.

COVID-19: short-time work
Austria | 06 May 2020

Austria pioneered short-time work schemes. Introduced in 1949 and overhauled in 2008 and 2009 during the financial crisis, the Austrian short-time work scheme has recently been further adapted to the particular needs of the COVID-19 crisis. This article examines who is eligible for the short-time work scheme and what subsidies are available.

Collective agreements trump Working Time Act
Austria | 18 March 2020

Following amendments to the Working Time Act, it was unclear whether the new statutory regime regarding working time overrides collective bargaining agreements that have not been adapted to the new maximum work hours and provide for a daily maximum of 10 working hours for flexitime. In the first decision on this issue, which will have far-reaching consequences, the Supreme Court has clarified all relevant questions regarding the collective bargaining agreement for metal workers.

Gig economy un-gigged: collective bargaining agreement for bike couriers
Austria | 18 December 2019

From 1 January 2020, bike couriers' employment relationships will be governed by a newly enacted collective bargaining agreement. Bike couriers in Austria now enjoy rights and benefits which are similar to employees in other sectors. While this is good news for bike couriers, it remains to be seen whether customers will have to pay the bill because of increased prices for courier services.

Teachers and brothels
Austria | 02 October 2019

The Supreme Court recently confirmed an appellate court's decision and ruled that a school teacher who had moonlighted as a brothel manager had been eligible for termination because this sort of behaviour could be considered a breach of trust and damaging to the school's reputation. The case was eventually decided in view of the perceived criminality of sex workers and their employers among the general public. However, this perception arguably depends on who is asked.

New 'daddy month' strengthens paternal bonding early on
Austria | 31 July 2019

Parliament recently passed a new law that grants fathers a legal entitlement to one month off work following the birth of their child. Dubbed the 'daddy month' by the media, this entitlement seeks to fill a gap that puts fathers at a disadvantage when it comes to childcare immediately following the birth of their child.

Supreme Court on hairstyles and discrimination
Austria | 08 May 2019

An employee recently sued for damages and compensation for gender discrimination when his job application was rejected because he had long hair. Originally unsuccessful, when the employee learned that the defendant's employee handbook contained rules on employees' outer appearance, he sued again and succeeded, as the Supreme Court found that the employee handbook was prima facie evidence of gender discrimination.

ECJ rules on Austria's Good Friday dilemma
Austria | 27 February 2019

The European Court of Justice advocate general recently confirmed that the Austrian regulation which sets out that Good Friday is a paid public holiday only for members of four specific churches is discriminatory. Further, the advocate general concluded that each affected employee could claim holiday pay for past periods, unless such claims were already time barred, in which case claims could be brought against the Austrian state.

Strikes and right to strike
Austria | 12 December 2018

It is widely understood that the Austrian concept of 'social partnership' (ie, the system for cooperation between the two sides of industry) has largely contributed to peaceful industrial relations. The social partnership recently agreed on a new collective bargaining agreement for the metal industry. However, negotiations in several other trades and industries have followed, and in a less constructive atmosphere, further strikes may be forthcoming.

Good Friday and direct discrimination on religious grounds
Austria | 03 October 2018

Under Austrian law, Good Friday is a paid public holiday only for members of four churches. An employee who belonged to none of these churches took issue with this and sued his employer. The case eventually reached the Supreme Court, which requested a preliminary ruling by the European Court of Justice (ECJ). In his recently issued opinion, the ECJ advocate general delivered what will likely also constitute the court's position on the matter.

Parliament passes new Working Time Act
Austria | 18 July 2018

Parliament recently passed a new law that brings sweeping changes to the Working Time Act and will come into effect on 1 September 2018. The law – which was heavily debated in the media and caused much controversy among the 'social partnership' (the Austrian system for cooperation between the two sides of industry) – sets the stage for more flexibility in a changing work environment.

Employed or self-employed? Request an advance ruling!
Austria | 09 May 2018

Determining whether an individual is an employee or self-employed can be risky for both the contractor and engager. Often, no one knows exactly how to qualify an individual until the national insurer claims arrears in social security payments in the wake of an audit. The parties involved hardly ever have legal certainty in advance. The Social Security Determination Act aims to change that.

Accurate and complimentary – difficult standard for recommendation letters
Austria | 07 February 2018

Under Austrian law, a recommendation letter must be truthful and cannot contain language that would aggravate the professional advancement of the employee. When truthfulness would result in less than lavish praise, employers must resort to a short-form recommendation letter, devoid of any information beyond the type of work performed and the duration of employment. This alternative, although accurate in its lack of praise, can aggravate an employee's career prospects.

Blue-collar and white-collar employees – sweetening the deal
Austria | 06 December 2017

In its final session before the general election, Parliament passed a bill which serves as a first step in harmonising the different legal regimes covering blue-collar and white-collar employees. However, not everyone is happy with this half-hearted harmonisation project – most notably, employer organisations – as they believe that the extended notice period for blue-collar workers will cost employers dearly.

Up in smoke: new law favours non-smokers in pub over workplace
Austria | 04 October 2017

As of May 1 2018 smoking in restaurants and bars will be prohibited. The restrictions on smoking in the workplace will also be tightened as of this date. However, the new provisions still afford some leeway to employers in that they can organise smoking breakrooms. As a consequence, the workplace may be more smoker friendly than pubs – who would have imagined that.

Vocational reintegration through novel part-time model
Austria | 26 July 2017

New legislation recently came into effect that aims to ease the process of reintegration into the workplace for employees who have been on extended sick leave and who would benefit from a reduced workload in order to aid rehabilitation and reconnect with the workplace. Although it is a well-meant initiative to curb the increase in long-term sickness, the legal framework reveals some major flaws.

2017 brings improvements for works councils and older employees
Austria | 26 April 2017

Two recent amendments to the Labour Relations Act benefit the legal status of works councils and are geared towards increasing older employees' job prospects. In particular, the term of office for members of a works council has been extended from four to five years. Works council members' entitlement to educational leave has also been extended. Further, the special treatment of employees who start employment at age 50 or older has been abolished.

Supreme Court rules on scope of German minimum wage legislation
Austria | 08 February 2017

The Supreme Court recently ruled on the thin line between the freedoms to provide services afforded under EU law and member states' legislation to contain social dumping, which can be extended to employers of other member states when they perform their services abroad. The decision clarifies that foreign minimum wage legislation will be avoided where its application poses an undue burden on employers and where it can be guaranteed that the purpose of minimum wage legislation is not undermined.

Supreme Court on discriminatory retirement policy
Austria | 07 December 2016

The Supreme Court recently ruled that a retirement policy which makes redundant all employees who are entitled to early retirement is discriminatory and, as a direct form of age discrimination, cannot be justified by claiming that such a policy amounts to a socially compatible form of redundancy. The decision indicates that the requirement to consider social selection and weigh social hardship can also qualify as a justification for age discrimination.

Supreme Court bans niqab
Austria | 28 September 2016

The Supreme Court recently ruled that the wearing of a niqab need not be tolerated by an employer because, although religious dress is protected under anti-discrimination legislation, it is one of the basic rules of interpersonal communication that facial expressions be visible. Further, although an employer's prohibition on religious dress amounts to direct religious discrimination, this ban can be justified as an occupational requirement.

Quest for another public holiday
Austria | 06 July 2016

In a recent decision with potentially far-reaching consequences, the Court of Appeals for the Vienna Circuit ruled that a peculiar provision in the Act on Rest Periods violates EU law and must therefore be disregarded by the courts. The court of appeals gave leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. If the Supreme Court hears the case and upholds the court of appeal's decision, Austrian employees may soon celebrate yet another public holiday.

Supreme Court on pink ribbons
Austria | 27 April 2016

The Supreme Court recently sought to set the standard for an employer's right to introduce or enforce a dress code. Basing its decision on the privacy rights under the Civil Code and the European Convention on Human Rights, the court clarified that an employee's outer appearance is his or her private affair, and that the test to be applied as to where this privacy ends is trustworthiness. Although clear-cut in theory, the guidance leaves considerable leeway for interpretation.

New employment legislation 2016
Austria | 20 January 2016

The new year has brought some substantive changes in employment legislation, including new minimum working time reductions for parental part-time work and new requirements for job offers under which employers must first offer job openings to part-time employees. Further changes include new laws and regulations in relation to non-compete agreements, all-in salaries and overtime and working time provisions.

Beware of foreign contract templates
Austria | 28 October 2015

Imagine that a foreign entity employing Austrian staff in Austria asks its Austrian employees to sign a standard employment agreement template and then tries to terminate one of those employment relationships under Austrian law. Those were the facts underlying a recent Supreme Court decision, wherein the court concluded that the termination of an employment relationship was governed by the laws of the foreign employer, not Austrian law.

Supreme Court rules on alcohol testing
Austria | 19 August 2015

The Supreme Court recently ruled on whether and how an employer can request that employees submit to alcohol testing. The court qualified the employer's unannounced breathalyser tests as a control measure that affected human dignity and thus required the works council's prior consent. This decision has left some questions for employers, as it is almost impossible to comply with strict safety standards without unannounced testing.

Non-compete clauses – Supreme Court changes longstanding position
Austria | 29 April 2015

For decades it was settled case law that compensating (or promising to compensate) a new hire for contractual penalties owed by the employee to his or her former competitor employer for breaching a non-compete clause amounted to anti-competitive practice, and both the former employee and new employer were liable under the Unfair Competition Act. However, the Supreme Court recently reversed this case law.

Do share sales trigger works council's information and consultation rights?
Austria | 11 February 2015

In line with the EU Transfer of Undertakings Directive, share sales do not trigger the works council's information or consultation rights. However, the provisions transposing the EU directive into Austrian law are not the only statutory rules that must be observed when it comes to share sales. As such, share sales with substantial operational changes trigger works council rights that far exceed those that apply under the EU directive.

Let's rock during sick leave
Austria | 12 November 2014

In a recent decision the Supreme Court had to consider whether activities performed during an employee's sick leave that would not typically be regarded as adequate conduct were acceptable. The Supreme Court confirmed the lower courts' decisions and opined that the plaintiff had only followed his doctor's instructions and that he could rely on this advice.

Who pays for employee surveillance by detective?
Austria | 27 August 2014

The Supreme Court has upheld a lower court decision which dismissed an employer's claim that an employee should be liable for surveillance costs incurred by his employer. The decision reminds employers to think twice before incurring costs for detective surveillance of employees, as they can claim those costs from employees only where surveillance confirms misconduct and the misconduct warrants a valid, actionable claim.

Knowledge imputation in employment law
Austria | 11 June 2014

Austrian law generally allows for imputation or attribution of knowledge to a principal where an agent, in the course of performing that task, learns something about a third party that has legal relevance to the principal's relationship with that third party. Employers should establish functioning reporting lines or risk knowledge being imputed to their detriment.

Supreme Court rules on social justification for dismissals
Austria | 09 April 2014

Under Austrian law, employees are granted protection against a termination of employment that lacks social justification. This means that employees can challenge their termination before the courts if it results in detrimental consequences that exceed the usual negative effects of a termination. The Supreme Court recently summed up the previous case law on the issue and specified what amounts to 'unusual' consequences.

Subsidised leaves of absence offer improved work-life balance
Austria | 05 February 2014

In recent years, extended education-oriented programmes (eg, for educational leave and other subsidised leaves of absence) have set a precedent for allowing employees to find a work-life balance in an increasingly competitive work environment. Employees who are dismissed because of their intention to take educational or family care leave, or because of the actual leave taken, can challenge the dismissal as unfair.

Supreme Court finds national origin comments discriminatory
Austria | 20 November 2013

The Supreme Court recently ruled that dismissal of an employee because of his or her national origin is deemed to constitute unlawful workplace discrimination based on ethnic grounds. Employers would be well advised to communicate clearly to staff that harassment, including offhand remarks or other verbal conduct, directed towards any ethnic or national group is unlawful.

Supreme Court considers works council consent as act of revenge
Austria | 04 September 2013

Austrian legislation protects employees against the socially unjustified termination of employment. The Supreme Court recently clarified that an employer is not obliged or authorised to examine the decision-making process of a works council regarding its consent to the termination of an employee, provided that the employer was unaware of any illegality concerning the internal decision-making process of the works council.

Supreme Court rules on paid leave for works council members
Austria | 05 June 2013

In a recent decision the Supreme Court clarified that arrangements by works council members for a paid leave of absence are not enforceable if they go beyond the limits set forth in the Labour Relations Act. The court made it clear that the paid leave in the agreement at hand exceeded the benefits that works council members could accept in exchange for their honorary post and violated the concept of volunteering.

Supreme Court issues clarification on age discrimination
Austria | 27 March 2013

The Supreme Court recently clarified a conceptual question concerning age discrimination. The case was unique in that the plaintiff was the only contender for the job and the vacancy was never filled. The court had to decide whether discrimination could occur even in the absence of a person with whom the applicant's situation could be compared.

Supreme Court demands quick response from employers following harassment
Austria | 16 January 2013

Employers must respond quickly when defending employees against mobbing attacks and harassment by their peers, a recent Supreme Court decision has confirmed. The court made clear that although an employer is free to choose any means necessary to protect its employees against such behaviour in the workplace, measures must be taken without delay.

Temporary Employment Act finally amended in line with EU directive
Austria | 14 November 2012

Although Austria has had a statutory framework in place since 1988 regulating the relationship between temporary workers, their employers and the entity to which they are assigned, the legislature was slow to implement the regulations set forth in the EU Directive on Temporary Agency Work. In order to adopt the directive's provisions, the Temporary Employment Act will shortly be amended accordingly and signed into law.

Changes to pension system promise flexibility and protection
Austria | 29 August 2012

Confidence in occupational retirement schemes has been lost over the years due to financial crises current and past, incorrect investment decisions and lax oversight. Many employees transferred their pension rights to defined contribution models hoping for higher returns, but instead suffered losses. The recent amendment of the Pension Fund Act aims to mitigate potential negative effects on occupational pensions.

Several collective bargaining agreements within one company
Austria | 23 May 2012

Austrian law requires companies to be members of the Chamber of Commerce. In general, the applicability of a collective bargaining agreement is determined through mandatory membership of the relevant division of the Chamber of Commerce; the division to which a company belongs depends on the employer's trade/business and corresponding business licence.

Supreme Court rules on sexual harassment and vicarious liability
Austria | 14 March 2012

In two recent decisions the Supreme Court clarified employer liability for harassment perpetrated by employees. The decision demonstrates that sexual harassment by the employer can also be perpetrated by the victim's superior. In such case the employer will be (vicariously) liable even where the harassment was the first such conduct of its kind.

Supreme Court rules on termination indemnity and old-age pensions
Austria | 30 November 2011

The Supreme Court recently clarified that the termination indemnity for commercial agents can be forfeited if an agent has terminated the agency contract for retirement reasons other than reaching the regular retirement age. Agents would be well advised to consider the implications for their termination indemnity and principals have been granted yet another reason to avoid payment of the indemnity once an agent retires.

Restrictive covenants: court rules on enforceability of non-compete clauses
Austria | 14 September 2011

Austrian law allows employers and employees to enter into non-compete agreements. The law distinguishes between restrictions of competing activities during employment and restrictive covenants pertaining to post-termination periods. Whether a restrictive covenant on post-termination periods is enforceable depends on how, and by whom, the employment relationship was terminated.

Primer on dismissals, redundancies and severance pay
Austria | 15 June 2011

In order to carry out dismissals and mass terminations, the Austrian legal regime requires the employer to give prior notification to the appropriate agency and observe the relevant terms. Additionally, the regime provides for staggered severance pay, increasing with seniority, if the termination of employment is not initiated or primarily caused by the employee.

Supreme Court rules on 'mystery flyers'
Austria | 23 February 2011

The Supreme Court recently clarified the scope of a works council's right to freedom of information under the Labour Relations Act. The employer, an airline, intended to evaluate its quality of service using so-called 'mystery flyers'. The information gathered was passed on to the airlines works council, which made several inquiries, requesting further information.

Data protection for employers - rights and obligations
Austria | 01 December 2010

In general, companies can collect employees' personal data. A prerequisite for the lawful processing of non-sensitive personal data is that it does not infringe an employee's legitimate interest in the confidentiality of the data. This condition is met if there is an explicit legal authorisation or duty to carry out the processing and the data subject has expressly agreed to, or has a vital interest in, such processing.

Formation and basic rights of European works councils under Austrian law
Austria | 15 September 2010

The European Works Council Directive imposed obligations on EU member states to establish a European works council or a procedure to inform and consult employees. Austria implemented these obligations by way of an amendment to the Labour Relations Act. The act provides for specific rules on the composition of a European works council, including rules on the number of members and the allocation of seats.

Secondment: the tripartite relationship
Austria | 16 June 2010

The Act on Secondment is broad in scope and basically applies to any scenario in which employees are seconded to a third party. The law's purpose is to provide rules which protect the labour and social rights of the seconded employees. Secondment creates a tripartite relationship between a temporary employment agency, the employer and the employee.

Entitlements to overtime pay
Austria | 31 March 2010

The Working Time Act defines 'overtime' as a period of working hours that exceeds either the maximum daily amount (eight hours) or the maximum weekly amount (40 hours) of standard working hours. Unless otherwise provided by collective bargaining agreements, a 50% premium is added to the normal hourly wage for calculating overtime pay.

Rules on working hours and statutory rest periods relaxed
Austria | 20 January 2010

Recent legislation has amended certain ingrained and inflexible rules on statutory working hours and conferred on staff representatives and employers legal powers to deviate mutually from the usual framework. Generally, standard working hours are up to eight hours per day and up to 40 hours per week; however, now they may be exceeded up to certain limits under certain circumstances.

Whistleblowing Hotlines: Employment and Data Protection Issues
Austria | 28 October 2009

Following the demise of Enron and ensuing US legislation, US companies have introduced mechanisms to safeguard the compliance of their European operations with the new legal framework. Such mechanisms have included implementing codes of conduct or ethics, which often provide for a whistleblowing hotline. The issue of whether the implementation of such codes is in line with Austrian legislation is twofold.

Supreme Court Rules on Inadequate Publication of Collective Agreement
Austria | 29 July 2009

Under Austrian rules on collective bargaining, certain matters that affect the interests of staff are subject to regulation at plant level. Section 30 of the Labour Relations Act specifically requires that employers must make employees aware of any such plant agreements. In a recent Supreme Court case the employer failed to publish a plant agreement adequately, costing it dearly.

Kurzarbeit: An Alternative to Lay-Offs
Austria | 27 May 2009

In response to the global economic downturn, Austria has in place a system wherein employers are permitted to reduce their employees' working hours while keeping the employment relationship intact. In accordance with this system, employers pay their employees government-subsidized special allowances instead of regular pay in order to cover most of the earnings shortfall.

Self-employed Eligible for Unemployment Benefits
Austria | 04 March 2009

Unemployment insurance is compulsory for all employees. Employers and employees must each contribute 3% to the social security provider. Since January 1 2009 self-employed indiviuals can opt into the system. It is hoped that this support programme will foster entrepreneurship and expand the Austrian social system.

Supreme Court Rules on Performance-Related Pay
Austria | 17 December 2008

A recent Supreme Court decision could have broad ramifications for employers that seek to raise individual employee performance by incentivizing their salary systems. Regardless of obtaining express consent from each individual employee, the court has ruled that such a system is voidable without prior consent from the works council.

Are Employers Obliged to Provide Works Council Members with Office Equipment?
Austria | 22 October 2008

In a recent decision the Supreme Court had to decide whether an employer was obliged to pay for office equipment needed by works council members to perform their representative roles on behalf of the workforce. The court concluded that the employer must, at its own cost, provide the chairman of the works council with a mobile phone, a laptop computer and a personal digital assistant.

Restricted Information and Consultation Rights of Works Councils
Austria | 06 August 2008

According to Section 40 of the Labour Relations Act, a works council must be established by employees through an electoral process in companies where at least five employees are regularly employed. Certain changes to the ownership structure of an employing entity may require notification of the works council.

Private Use of PCs and Mobile Phones
Austria | 14 May 2008

In a recent decision the Supreme Court reiterated previous case law concerning an employee’s private use of a mobile phone or other employer-provided electronic device. The court ruled that cause for dismissal is justified only if an employee uses for private purposes an electronic device provided by his or her employer under the express condition that it be exclusively used in a work-related context.

Amendment to Working Time Act Takes Effect
Austria | 12 March 2008

An amendment to the Working Time Act recently took effect. It brings with it sweeping changes and increased flexibility to maximum working hours. Its intention is to allow employers to adapt to a changing economic environment and at the same time grant legal protection to employees in connection with potential health hazards.

Outsourcing: The Effect on Employment
Austria | 28 November 2007

Austria has no codified piece of legislation that specifically regulates all aspects of outsourcing transactions. However, the legal ramifications with respect to employment are specifically set forth in the Employment Law Harmonization Act and the Labour Relations Act.

Legal Conditions in the Workplace
Austria | 17 October 2007

Austrian employment legislation is fully compliant with applicable EU regulations, yet it is still more flexible than the labour laws of other European jurisdictions. This update considers the legal framework that applies to working hours, tax duties and termination in the Austrian workplace.

Challenging Unfair Dismissal: The Three-Prong Test
Austria | 08 August 2007

Austrian legislation protects employees against socially unjustified termination of employment. This legal recourse regularly serves as a strong bargaining tool in case of redundancies. If an employee challenges his or her dismissal before the courts, a three-prong test is applied to determine whether the termination was justified.

Staff Relocation: Court Rules on Employer's Duties
Austria | 16 May 2007

If changes to a business structure proposed by an employer entail redundancies, the works council of the business unit has the legal power to force a social plan upon the employer. In the case of relocation, such a plan would typically provide compensation for increased travel expenses.

Supreme Court Rules on Disciplinary Procedures
Austria | 07 March 2007

Although uncommon under the Austrian legal framework governing labour relations and dispute resolution, some collective bargaining agreements contain disciplinary procedures that must be observed by an employer before dismissal or lesser disciplinary penalties.