We would like to ensure that you are still receiving content that you find useful – please confirm that you would like to continue to receive ILO newsletters.
28 February 2020
Digitalisation is changing the way businesses operate and new business models have become a growing challenge for existing international tax systems.
Under the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) project, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) is tackling the complex question of how to adapt international taxation systems to make them fit for the digital age. In this context, on 31 January 2020, the OECD released a statement update on building a new international framework for allocating part of the profits of multinational enterprises (MNEs) with a substantial digital business footprint in countries in which they have a large user base, but no physical presence (market jurisdictions). The statement update includes insights on business lines potentially in scope as well as more details on nexus and profit allocation rules. Many questions are still open and the international community, including Switzerland, will continue to work towards reaching an agreement on the key policy features by the end of 2020. This article provides an overview of the statement update and outlines Switzerland's position in this regard.
As per the current international income tax rules, business profits generated by an enterprise are taxable exclusively by the state of residence unless the enterprise conducts business in the source state through a permanent establishment (PE) situated therein. In other words, a country can tax a foreign enterprise only if there is a nexus through a certain level of physical presence in the respective country.
However, novel business models continue to erode the need for physical presence in target markets. As a consequence, many MNEs in the digital space (eg, Google, Amazon, Instagram and Facebook) are able to avoid taxation in market jurisdictions, lacking physical presence therein, while having a large user or consumer base in countries contributing to their annual revenues.
Against this backdrop, the OECD has been working on a two-pillar approach to adapt the existing international income tax rules to the changing modern global economy. While the first pillar addresses the broader challenges of the digitalised economy and focuses on the allocation of taxing rights, the second pillar refers to certain other BEPS issues.
Pillar One focuses on modifying the existing nexus and profit allocation rules to provide market jurisdictions with additional taxing rights. Accordingly, the new nexus rules would depart from the traditional PE concept and a portion of profits would be allocated among the different eligible market jurisdictions in which an MNE has no physical market presence.
Under Pillar Two, the focus is on introducing a minimum level of taxation and certain other measures yet to be defined to prevent the shifting of profits to low-tax jurisdictions.
The statement update released on 31 January 2020 provides further insight into Pillar One, focusing on the allocation of taxing rights, outlining its architecture and aim to include both automated digital and consumer-facing businesses in its scope. By contrast, for Pillar Two, only a high-level progress report on the OECD's work was released.
In summary, the statement update includes the following noteworthy new or clarified elements:
The definition of both categories has not yet been elaborated. By contrast, business selling intermediate products and components that are incorporated into a finished product sold to consumers, extractive industries, sellers of raw materials and commodities, most financial services (including insurance) as well as airline and shipping businesses are likely to fall outside the scope of Pillar One.
Many important details and policy issues under the two pillars remain unresolved and various countries have introduced or proposed unilateral measures to impose new taxes on digital service providers. This has increased pressure on the OECD to reach a consensus-based solution to tax the digital economy by the end of 2020 to avoid such unilateral actions in future.
In connection with the statement update, Switzerland assured that it would maintain its support for the development of a multilateral solution for taxing the digital economy to avoid unilateral actions that jeopardise growth and innovation. Further, Switzerland takes the stance that:
Switzerland further expects that smaller, innovative and export-based economies such as Switzerland will lose out on income tax receipts once the existing international income tax rules will have been adapted.
For further information on this topic please contact Fabienne Limacher or Maurus Winzap at Walder Wyss by telephone (+41 58 658 58 58) or email (email@example.com or firstname.lastname@example.org). The Walder Wyss website can be accessed at www.walderwyss.com.
The materials contained on this website are for general information purposes only and are subject to the disclaimer.
ILO is a premium online legal update service for major companies and law firms worldwide. In-house corporate counsel and other users of legal services, as well as law firm partners, qualify for a free subscription.