Your Subscription

We would like to ensure that you are still receiving content that you find useful – please confirm that you would like to continue to receive ILO newsletters.





Login
Twitter LinkedIn




Login
  • Home
  • About
  • Updates
  • Awards
  • Contact
  • Directory
  • OnDemand
  • Partners
  • Testimonials
Forward Share Print

Working Time: ECJ Rules on Status of On-Call Working

Newsletters

29 October 2003

Employment & Immigration European Union


In September 2003 the European Court of Justice (ECJ) gave an important ruling on the status of time 'on-call' (Landeshauptstadt Kiel v Jaeger). The case, referred by the German courts, concerned a hospital doctor who was required to spend a certain part of the day on-call and was allocated a room with a bed in the hospital to be available to deal with emergencies. Under German law, 'on-call service' (where an employee is obliged to be present at a place determined by the employer and to keep himself available to answer a call, even if he can rest or occupy his time as he wishes while his services are not required) and 'standby service' (where an employee can be where he likes, as long as he is contactable and can be called upon at short notice to perform duties) are deemed not to constitute 'working time'.

The ECJ held that all on-call duty performed by a doctor required to be present in a hospital constitutes 'working time' for the purposes of the Working Time Directive. This will be the case even where the doctor sleeps at the hospital when his services are not required, and periods of sleep or inactivity do not amount to rest periods. The ECJ noted that, in contrast to a doctor on standby, a doctor who is required to keep himself available at a place determined by his employer during on-call duty is subject to

"appreciably greater constraints, since he has to remain apart from his family and social environment and has less freedom to manage the time during which his professional services are not required. Under those conditions an employee available at the place determined by the employer cannot be regarded as being at rest during the periods of his on-call duty when he is not actually carrying on any professional activity."

This follows, but develops, a 2000 ECJ ruling concerning the on-call duties of doctors in Spain.

While the case concerned German law and the health sector, it is of wider significance as an interpretation of the Working Time Directive. It remains to be seen how the ECJ ruling is applied elsewhere in Europe. It is, however, of potentially broad application. If 'working time' is any period where the employee is required to be at a place determined by the employer to be available for duties, this could cover any situation where he or she is at his or her employer's disposal and away from home - for example a business trip.


For further information on this topic please contact Mark Mansell or Felicity Gemson at Allen & Overy by telephone (+44 20 7330 3000) or by fax (+44 20 7330 9999) or by email (mark.mansell@allenovery.com or felicity.gemson@allenovery.com).

The materials contained on this website are for general information purposes only and are subject to the disclaimer.

ILO is a premium online legal update service for major companies and law firms worldwide. In-house corporate counsel and other users of legal services, as well as law firm partners, qualify for a free subscription.

Forward Share Print

Author

Mark Mansell

Mark Mansell

Register now for your free newsletter

View recent newsletter

More from this firm

  • EU member states must require employers to record working time systematically
  • Correct implementation of employment contracts: favourability assessment in case of dispute
  • Correct implementation of employment contracts: choice of law and applicable law
  • Cross-border reorganisation – transfers of foreign units to domestic companies
  • Cross-border reorganisation – foreign companies with a local branch

More articles

  • Home
  • About
  • Updates
  • Awards
  • Contact
  • My account
  • Directory
  • OnDemand
  • Partners
  • Testimonials
  • Follow on Twitter
  • Follow on LinkedIn
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • GDPR Compliance
  • Terms
  • Cookie policy
Online Media Partners
Inter-Pacific Bar Association (IPBA) International Bar Association (IBA) European Company Lawyers Association (ECLA) Association of Corporate Counsel (ACC) American Bar Association Section of International Law (ABA)

© 1997-2021 Law Business Research

You need to be logged in to make a comment. Log in here.
Many thanks. Your comment has been sent.

Your details



Your comment or question *