Under the Tax Administration Act, a Tax Court judgment regarding an appeal under the dispute resolution provisions contained in the act must be published for general information purposes. The South African Revenue Service recently published a raft of Tax Court judgments that have thus far been handed down in 2017, which provide for interesting reading and cover a broad range of procedural and administrative issues.
The Tax Court recently addressed the question of whether a taxpayer is entitled to condonation for the late filing of an appeal under the Tax Administration Act. The Tax Court referred to a Constitutional Court judgment which found that a delay cannot be a determining factor in condonation applications. In addition, it noted that other important considerations should be taken into account, such as whether the omission or failure was the applicant's fault and the extent of the delay.
Section 12O of the Income Tax Act provides an incentive to stimulate the domestic production of films in the form of an exemption from normal tax for income derived from the exploitation rights of a film. The South African Revenue Service recently issued guidance reflecting its interpretation of this provision.
Following the implementation of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development's Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Action Plans, which impose country-by-country reporting requirements on multinational enterprises, taxpayers can no longer – or at least cannot easily – strategically escape taxation by shifting their profits to low or no-tax jurisdictions. This is because the South African Revenue Service has become aware of issues regarding tax avoidance and is actively taking steps to address them.
Under the Value Added Tax Act, vendors were previously prohibited from claiming notional input tax deductions for the acquisition of second-hand goods comprising gold or goods containing gold in an attempt to curb fraudulent notional input tax deductions regarding the acquisition of gold and gold jewellery. However, the amendment had a negative impact on legitimate transactions in the industry, so the definition of second-hand goods was recently amended in order to limit the extent of the exclusion.
The Mthatha High Court recently ruled that the South African Revenue Service (SARS) had failed to comply with Section 96 of the Tax Administration Act in ordering an additional assessment of a taxpayer's income tax. The case reaffirms the fact that just as taxpayers have a duty to pay tax, SARS has duties that it must fulfil in order to be entitled to collect this tax.
South African Revenue Services decisions are generally subject to the internal remedy available under Section 9 of the Tax Administration Act. However, decisions that are given effect to in an assessment or notice of assessment are excluded, since assessments generally have the separate remedy of objection and appeal. A recent memorandum on the Draft Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill proposes that such decisions be subject to the remedy under Section 9 of the act.
There has been a great deal of uncertainty surrounding the claiming of value added tax (VAT) input credits, particularly where mixed taxable and non-taxable supplies are made and in the context of expenses relating to corporate actions. This uncertainty regarding the deductibility of input tax credits in certain instances has created a VAT risk for many vendors. The courts and the South African Revenue Service have differing views on this matter.